MAG Renewal 2019: General guidance

Internet Governance Forum (IGF)

2019 Renewal of the Multistakeholder Advisory Group (MAG)

General guidance and notes to take into consideration regarding nominations for a position on the MAG



The Internet Governance Forum (IGF) Multistakeholder Advisory Group (MAG) was established by the United Nations Secretary-General in 2006 to assist the Secretary-General in convening the annual IGF Meeting by advising on the programme and schedule. MAG members serve in their personal capacity, but are expected to have established linkages within stakeholder communities. More information is available in the MAG Terms of References

The United Nations Secretary-General appoints members, with careful consideration of the recommendations made by stakeholder groups and nominations from the broader community. The overall composition of the MAG should have a regional, stakeholder and gender balance and in this light nominators are requested to review past and returning MAG member affiliations. Further, the Secretary-General launched the gender parity strategy in September 2017 as part of a system-wide campaign to advance this priority at the United Nations.

Members coming from the Government stakeholder group may hold up to 40% of the total number of seats on the MAG, with the remaining percentage shared equally across the three other stakeholder groups, i.e. civil society, private sector and the technical community. Individual appointments are for a one (1)-year term, with a maximum of three (3) consecutive terms. The total number of members on the MAG should be fifty (50) in 2019, for the purposes of rationalizing the overall process. These numbers have fluctuated in the past due largely to the fact that returning members have occasionally changed stakeholder groups.

Former IGF Host Countries hold one seat each on the MAG. Treaty-based intergovernmental organizations can also hold observer seats on the MAG

Countries that were not represented or were under-represented in previous MAG compositions will have an advantage over those that have had continuous or frequent representation on the MAG.

At the end of the 2018 IGF cycle, nineteen (19) MAG members are due to be rotated out, as they have served a full three (3)-year term and one (1) member that is eligible to continue serving, but has expressed a request of no longer being able to serve on the MAG

Each of the MAG members rotating out is freeing up one seat for the regional and stakeholder group they initially occupied. 

Given the overall aim for the MAG 2019 to be composed of fifty (50) MAG members, this year’s nominations announcement calls for the following number of seats:

 

  • Stakeholder Group Balance
Stakeholder Group 2018 Rotations Available seats for the MAG 2019 Renewal
Government 9 (out of 23) 6 (to equal 20)
Civil Society 5 (out of 11) 4 (to equal 10)
Private Sector 2 (out of 11) 1 (to equal 10)
Technical Community 3 (out of 10) 3 (to equal 10)
Total 19 (out of 55)  14 (total seats = 50)

 

  • Regional Group Balance
Regional Group 2018 Rotations Available seats for the MAG 2019 Renewal
Africa 4 (out of 11) 3 (to equal 10)
Asia Pacific 7 (out of 13) 5 (to equal 11)
Eastern Europe 1 (out of 10) 0 (to equal 9)
GRULAC 4 (out of 11) 4 (to equal 10)
WEOG 3 (out of 11) 2 (to equal 10)
Total 19 (out of 55) 14 (total seats = 50)

 

  • Gender Balance

The 2019 MAG composition will aim for parity in terms of gender representation.

Excluding the members that are due to be rotated out, the breakdown per gender of the remaining members that are eligible to continue serving, is: 18 female and 18 male members. This indicates  that the 2019 MAG renewal will aim for appointing 7 female MAG members and 7 male MAG members, resulting in equal gender distribution within the overall MAG composition. 

Given the gender of the members that are due to rotate out, this Renewal, however, may not result in parity within each stakeholder group in each regional group. In the long term, the MAG composition will aim for having equal distribution of female and male members within each stakeholder group in each region (e.g. 2 female and 2 male members in the Governmental stakeholder groups; 1 female and 1 male member in all other stakeholder groups, across all regions).

Nevertheless, this Renewal will aim to have, as close as possible, gender parity  across stakeholder and regional groups, and therefore calling for nomination consideration of  the following seats:

 

Proposed seats per Regional and Stakeholder Groups (50) Government (20) Civil Society (10) Private 

Sector (10)
Technical Community (10)
Africa (10)

1 female member (leading to 2 female and 2 male members).
1 male member (leading to 1 female and 1 male member). No rotations.

Group composed of 2 male members.
1 male member (leading to 1 female and 1 male member).
Asia Pacific (11) 1 female member and 1 male member (leading to 2 female and 2 male members). 1 female member (leading to 2 female members). 1 female member (leading to 2 female and 1 male member)1. 1 female member (leading to 1 female and 1 male member).
Eastern Europe (9) No rotations.

Group composed of 3 male and 1 female member.
No rotations.

Group composed of 2 female members.
Not adding new member2 (leading to 1 female member). No rotations.

Group composed of 2 male members.
GRULAC (10) 1 male member (leading to 2 female and 2 male members). 1 female, 1 male (leading to 1 female and 1 male member). No rotations.

Group composed of 1 female and 1 male member.
1 male member (leading to 1 female and 1 male member).
WEOG (10) 1 female member and 1 male member (leading to 2 female and 2 male members). No rotations.

Group composed of 1 female and 1 male member.
No rotations. Group composed of 2 male members. No rotations.

Group composed of 2 female members.

 

  • Countries Representation

As noted above, countries that were not represented or were underrepresented in previous MAG compositions, will have an advantage over those that have had continuous or frequent representation on the MAG. Below is the historical overview of countries’ representation per the UN regional groups, with indication in parentheses in case of multiyear representation:

AFRICA

Countries that have been represented on the MAG: Algeria, Benin, Burundi, Cameroon, Egypt (5), Gambia, Ghana (3), Ivory Coast, Kenya (5), Mauritius (2), Morocco, Namibia, Nigeria ‎‎(9), Niger, Senegal (4), South Africa (4), Sudan, Tunisia , Uganda (3), Zambia, Zimbabwe.

Countries that have not been represented on the MAG: Angola, Botswana, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cabo Verde, Central African Republic, Chad, Comoros, Congo, DR Congo, Djibouti, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Gabon, Guinea-Bissau, Lesotho, Liberia, Libya,  Madagascar, Malawi, Mali, Mauritania, Mozambique, Rwanda, Sao Tome and Principe, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, Somalia, South Sudan, Swaziland, Togo, UR Tanzania.

ASIA PACIFIC

Countries that have been represented on the MAG: Afghanistan, Bangladesh (3), China (14), Fiji (2), India (6), Indonesia (2), Iran (2), ‎Japan (5), Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Malaysia, Pakistan (4), Philippines, Republic of Korea (2), Saudi Arabia, ‎Singapore, Sri Lanka (2), Thailand, Vanuatu, Vietnam.

Countries that have not been represented on the MAG: Bahrain, Bhutan, Brunei Darussalam,  Cyprus, Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, Iran (Islamic Republic of), Kazakhstan,  Kiribati, Kyrgyzstan, Lao People's Republic, Maldives, Marshall Islands, Micronesia (Federated, States of), Mongolia, Myanmar, Nauru, Nepal, Oman, Palau, Papua New Guinea,  Qatar, Samoa, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Solomon Islands, Syrian Arab Republic, Tajikistan,  Timor-Leste, Tonga, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Tuvalu, United Arab Emirates, Uzbekistan, Yemen.

EASTERN EUROPE

Countries that have been represented on the MAG: Azerbaijan, Armenia, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina (3), Bulgaria (3), Croatia (2), Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary (2), ‎Latvia, Lithuania (2), Macedonia, Moldova, Poland, Romania (2), Russia (7), Serbia (3), Slovakia, Ukraine.

Countries that have not been represented on the MAG: Albania, Georgia, Montenegro, Slovenia.

GRULAC

Countries that have been represented on the MAG: Antigua and Barbuda, Argentina (5), Barbados (2), Brazil (8), Chile (2), Colombia (3), Costa Rica (2), Cuba, ‎Ecuador (2), El Salvador, Jamaica, Mexico (2), Paraguay, Peru (2), Suriname, Trinidad and Tobago (2), ‎Uruguay (3), Venezuela.

Countries that have not been represented on the MAG: Bahamas, Belize,  Bolivia (Plurinational State of), Dominica,  Dominican Republic, Grenada, Guatemala, Guyana, Haiti, Honduras, Nicaragua, Panama, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. 

WEOG

Countries that have been represented on the MAG: Australia (6), Austria, Belgium (3), Canada (3), Finland (4), France (5), Germany (5), ‎Greece, Italy (2), Netherlands (2), New Zealand (3), Portugal, Spain (3), Sweden (4), Switzerland, UK (8), ‎USA (19).‎

Countries that have not been represented on the MAG: Andorra, Denmark, Iceland, Ireland,  Israel, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Malta, Monaco, Norway, San Marino.



Former IGF Host Countries hold one permanent seat each on the MAG: Greece, Brazil, India, Egypt, Lithuania, Kenya, Azerbaijan,  Indonesia, Turkey, Brazil, Mexico and Switzerland.

 

*Please note that these breakdowns are provided for general guidance only, and that the overall composition depends on several considerations including the nominations received, as well as the final decision of the UN Secretary-General.

 

List of members that are due to be rotated out

The table below indicates the MAG members who have served three (3) consecutive terms on the MAG:

Title Last Name, First Name Regional Group Stakeholder Group Terms Served
Ms. Abdulla, Rasha Africa Civil Society 3 Terms
Ms. Aquino Ribeiro, Renata  GRULAC Civil Society 3 Terms
Mr. Casasbuenas, Julian  GRULAC Civil Society 3 Terms
Ms. Tamanikaiwaimaro, Salanieta  Asia Pacific Civil Society 3 Terms
Mr. Douglas, Onyango Africa Technical Community 3 Terms
Mr. Estrada, Miguel Ignacio4  GRULAC Technical Community 3 Terms
Mr. Sabir, Ahmed Sumon  Asia Pacific Technical Community 3 Terms
Mr. Bazlyankov, Iliya Eastern Europe Private Sector 3 Terms
Mr. Mansoor Ansari, Omar  Asia Pacific Private Sector 3 Terms
Ms. Bou Harb, Zeina  Asia Pacific Government 3 Terms
Mr. Donkor, Wisdom Africa Government 3 Terms
Mr. Cheon, Billy Mooho Asia Pacific Government 3 Terms
Ms. Erramuspe, Alejandra GRULAC Government 3 Terms
Ms. Franz I., Liesyl  WEOG Government 3 Terms
Mr. Muataz, Mohammed Africa Government 3 Terms
Mr. Pérez Galindo, Rafael  WEOG Government 3 Terms
Mr. Rhijn van, Arnold  WEOG Government 3 Terms
Ms. Soriano, Jianne* Asia Pacific Civil Society 1 Term
Mr. Wanawit, Akhuputra  Asia Pacific Government 3 Terms

*Member informed that no longer will serve on the MAG.

 

_______________________________________________________________________________________

1 Taking into account the scope of the region, and the fact that the IGF aims for increasing private sector participation, it is proposed to add one more member in this region. The Eastern European region is significantly smaller that others, and it is proposed not to add a new member for this Renewal.

2 Ibid.

4 During the 2016 term, the member has changed the initial stakeholder group from Government to Private Sector, and in 2017 to Technical Community. The changes have been made accordingly. The member will free the seat for the group he initially came in with (Government).