IGF 2024 WS #43 States and Digital Sovereignty: Infrastructural Challenges

    Organizer 1: Gabriela Nardy, NIC.br
    Organizer 2: Juliano Cappi, 🔒NIC.br
    Organizer 3: Oms Juliana, NIC.br
    Organizer 4: Tatiana Jereissati, 🔒
    Organizer 5: Rodolfo Avelino, Insper

    Speaker 1: Min Jiang, Civil Society, Asia-Pacific Group
    Speaker 2: Ritul Gaur, Civil Society, Asia-Pacific Group
    Speaker 3: Korstiaan Wapenaar, Private Sector, African Group
    Speaker 4: Renata Mielli, Government, Latin American and Caribbean Group (GRULAC)

    Moderator

    Rodolfo Avelino, Technical Community, Latin American and Caribbean Group (GRULAC)

    Online Moderator

    Oms Juliana, Technical Community, Latin American and Caribbean Group (GRULAC)

    Rapporteur

    Gabriela Nardy, Technical Community, Latin American and Caribbean Group (GRULAC)

    Format

    Roundtable
    Duration (minutes): 90
    Format description: The round table format favors multistakeholder engagement with presentation of different regional experiences and perspectives related to the issue addressed. It also allows an informal debate on pressing topics, such as the possible implications for state capacities of adopting digital infrastructures in strategic sectors, given the increasing demands for transparency, autonomy, security. The 90-minute duration facilitates the discussion of complex issues characterized by open disputes and multiple perspectives from different sectors and regions, and also for allowing time for the audience participation through questions & answers.

    Policy Question(s)

    1) How can different approaches of the digital sovereignty concept help to assess the implementation of digital infrastructure, considering the strengthening of state capacities in strategic sectors? 2) Given the increasing demands for transparency, autonomy, security, among others framed under the notion of digital sovereignty, what are the possible implications for states of adopting private digital infrastructures?

    What will participants gain from attending this session? Participants and attendees will benefit from the discussion of concrete policy and regulatory initiatives developed to strength state capacity. Moreover, the discussion will provide an assesment of policy initiatives based on different perspectives of the digital sovereignty concept. The exchange of concrete experiences and lessons learned about how different countries have attempted to address this matter contributes to find solutions for the implementation of good policy practices in different contexts.

    Description:

    The development of the Internet in the last decade was marked by the consolidation of large digital platforms, the increasing processes of datafication and the growing use of artificial intelligence (AI). Those transformations led to significant changes not only in a myriad of social processes, but also in essential public services, such as health, education, communication, and transport - areas that are increasingly being mediated by information and communication technologies (ICT). For instance, in universities, digital platforms are being used to store and share information, while in public health, records are being digitalized and shared between multiple actors. The digitization of these services contributes to the datafication of citizen and to systematic surveillance, as well as the outsourcing of technological solutions based on proprietary and closed-source software and infrastructure. Despite important technological advances and innovations generated by the business sector, it is argued that there has been a weakening in the state capacity to protect citizen privacy, to harness an open and inclusive innovation process and to enforce legislation in the digital environment. Problems of opacity, national security and autonomy to implement digital policies suggests a reduction of the public interest in essential areas. These issues can be framed under the concept of digital sovereignty, a notion that encompasses multiple meanings and purposes, raising themes such as the security of digital infrastructures, the security of strategic data of a territory, innovation, and the state's capacity to guarantee fundamental rights in the face of an increasing role of technologies. This session aims at assessing policies initiatives to implement digital infrastructures in different regions and countries in the light of different approaches of digital sovereignty

    Expected Outcomes

    Many basic digital infrastructures deployed by private actors are unknown by public agents and general citizens, who are not acquainted to the subject. Content Delivery Networks (CDNs), Internet Exchange Points, data centers, digital platforms, email-servers services, Internet backbones are exemples of this infraestructures. The workshop will provide: 1) examples of public police initiatives focused on different types of digital infrastructure; 2) a basic assessment of these initiatives based on the theoretical framework of digital sovereignty.

    Hybrid Format: The workshop will be divided into four parts: a) a opening and a presentation on different approaches for digital sovereignty; b) presentations on policy initiatives implemented in different countries, focusing on the policy objectives that guided the states decisions; c) a short debate among participants on the assessment of the initiatives, considering different dimensions of the concept of digital sovereignty; d) the last part will be devoted to Q&A. To ensure proper interaction between the audience, the session will count with onsite and online moderators. The onsite moderator will be responsible to oversee the interventions and interacting with the speakers, and also care for safeguarding the due balance to meet diversity expectations. The online moderator will take care of the flow of questions within all the online tools involved in the session. He/she will guarantee that the onsite moderator will be aware of questions and comments from the remote audience.